Seminal
The magazine and atlas of EU-funded researchA new publication from the web and AI team at Scott Charnley

Atlas / Spain

European Research Council grant · Running

ABDICATE From Verifiable Success to Epistemic Abdication: How General-Purpose AI Transforms Belief Formation and Collective Intelligence

Coordinator
Universidad Pompeu Fabra, Spain
Runs
1 August 2026 to 31 July 2031
Status
Running
EU funding
€2.5m
Total cost
—
Partners
1 organisations in 1 countries
Type
European Research Council grant
Grant agreement
101267544

What the project is doing

In the project's own words, from its summary on CORDIS.

General-purpose AI (GPAI) assistants like ChatGPT, Gemini, or Claude—accessed through a single interface—help users debug code, draft press releases, obtain political news, summarize parliamentary debates, and seek educational advice. Unlike specialized tools that signal domain boundaries, this uniform design obscures cues about where competence ends, forcing users to judge trustworthiness across domains where performance varies widely.

ABDICATE asks whether interface unity fosters epistemic abdication—the voluntary surrender of critical judgment, manifested as reduced skepticism and verification. Building on my research on belief formation, attitude dynamics, and generalization, I hypothesize that interface unity masks competence differences and enables cross-domain trust spillover: trust earned in verifiable tasks (grammar fixes, working code) transfers inappropriately to domains where errors, biases, or value misalignment are hard to detect (political news, educational advice).

ABDICATE delivers formal theory, controlled experiments, multi-wave panels, and a field experiment to identify the causal effects of GPAI design features—interface unity, persistent memory, sycophancy, answer plurality, and source display—on verification, belief formation, and attitudes. Calibrated computational models reveal when these features yield accuracy-convergent consensus, manufactured consensus from homogeneous outputs, or polarized divergence as personalization amplifies priors.

With ChatGPT at 700M weekly users, Gemini at 450M monthly users, and persistent memory becoming standard, epistemic habits formed now will determine whether democratic deliberation retains the independent judgment it requires. ABDICATE will provide evidence-based recommendations on GPAI default settings—e.g., default persistent memory (ON/OFF)—and compliance tools that help preserve citizens’ epistemic autonomy before path dependence makes intervention costly.

Who is involved

OrganisationCityCountryRole
Universidad Pompeu FabraBarcelonaSpainCoordinator

Source: CORDIS, European Commission. Data of 5 Nov 2026, reused under the Commission's reuse policy. View on CORDIS